Keep current plan
- Starting deductible left
- $800
- Deductible paid
- $800
- Coinsurance paid
- $1,040
- Total
- $5,080
Compare remaining-year health plan costs after a midyear switch, including deductible and out-of-pocket progress, premiums, coinsurance, and transfer credits.
Keep the current plan. Modeled difference $460.
Remaining-year comparison
Lower modeled cost
Keep the current plan
$460 less over the remaining 6 months under these assumptions.
Stay on current plan
$5,080
$3,240 premiums + $1,840 medical
Switch to new plan
$5,540
$2,340 premiums + $3,200 medical + $0 transition
Deductible progress not credited
$2,200
$2,700 of entered OOP progress not modeled as transferred
Where the remaining-year money goes
Switch to new plan
- Starting deductible left
- $2,500
- Deductible paid
- $2,500
- Coinsurance paid
- $700
- Total
- $5,540
The modeled plans cross near $1,925 of remaining covered allowed charges. Test spending above and below that amount.
Calculation scope
How this calculator works
The model subtracts confirmed progress from each deductible and out-of-pocket maximum, applies expected remaining charges to the deductible first, and applies coinsurance afterward. Remaining premiums and any entered transition cost are then added.
- • The comparison covers only the remaining months entered and treats expected spending as covered, in-network allowed charges.
- • A deductible credit is modeled only when entered. Confirm any transfer or transition-of-care credit with the new insurer before relying on it.
- • Copays, separate prescription deductibles, employer account funding, tax effects, and provider-network differences are excluded unless reflected in the entered transition cost.
Explore Personal Finance
Budgeting, debt payoff, and personal financial planning
View all personal finance calculators →Related Calculators
COBRA vs Spouse Plan vs Marketplace
Compare health coverage after a job loss using exact COBRA, spouse-plan, and Marketplace quotes, deductible progress, subsidies, and enrollment timing.
Embedded vs Aggregate Deductible
Run family claims in order to compare embedded and aggregate deductibles, premiums, coinsurance, and individual and family out-of-pocket thresholds.
Spouse Health Insurance Calculator
Compare two employer health plans across four family enrollment arrangements using premiums, eligibility, deductibles, coinsurance, and employer health-account funds.
HSA vs PPO vs FSA Calculator
Compare modeled HDHP + HSA and PPO + Health FSA costs, including tax effects, out-of-pocket costs, dependent care inputs, and paycheck impact.
Midyear coverage-change guide
What happens to your deductible when you change health plans
Changing jobs or insurance plans can restart the deductible and out-of-pocket totals even when the calendar year is only half over. A lower premium can still lose once that reset is included.
This calculator compares the remaining year only, so money already spent is treated as history rather than charged twice.
How to use this tool
Confirm current progress
Use the insurer portal or current explanation of benefits for deductible and out-of-pocket totals paid so far.
Ask about transfer credit
Do not assume progress transfers. Enter a credit only after the new insurer confirms the amount and eligible expenses.
Estimate remaining care
Use negotiated allowed amounts for prescriptions, visits, tests, therapy, and scheduled procedures.
Check the network separately
A cheaper mathematical result can still be a poor fit if providers, drugs, or authorizations change.
Common reasons a deductible resets
- A new employer uses a different insurance carrier or group plan.
- Coverage changes outside the employer’s open-enrollment cycle.
- A spouse moves from one employer plan to another.
- The new plan has a different plan year or cost-sharing design.
Questions to ask the new insurer
- Will any deductible or out-of-pocket progress be credited, and are those credit amounts different?
- Which claims and dates qualify for the credit?
- Will ongoing treatment receive transition-of-care protection?
- Are prescriptions subject to a separate deductible?
This tool does not determine whether deductible credit must be granted or whether a service is covered. Obtain written confirmation from the insurer or plan administrator and review provider networks, formularies, authorizations, COBRA rights, and effective dates separately.
Sources and further reading
- HealthCare.gov — Health insurance deductible glossary — General definition of the amount paid before a plan begins paying for covered services.
- U.S. Department of Labor — Health benefits coverage under COBRA — Federal overview of continuing employer coverage after qualifying events.
Frequently asked questions
Does my deductible automatically transfer to a new employer plan?
Usually not. Some insurers or plan transitions may offer a credit, but it should be confirmed with the new carrier or plan administrator before entering it here.
Should I include money already spent this year?
Enter it as current-plan deductible and out-of-pocket progress. Do not add it again to expected remaining charges, because the comparison covers only future cost.
Can keeping COBRA preserve my deductible progress?
COBRA generally continues the same group coverage, which may preserve plan-year accumulation, but premiums and eligibility details matter. Compare that option in the Job Loss Health Coverage calculator and confirm with the plan.
What is a deductible credit?
It is an amount the new insurer agrees to recognize from prior-plan spending. Terms vary, so this calculator asks for deductible credit and out-of-pocket credit separately.